nti.media
Phase 2 Records 66% Turnout Even as IED Blast, Police Firings, Mob Attacks and EVM Glitches Mar Voting - News18      |       Sadhvi Pragya Breaks Down Alleging "Torture" In Jail, Slams Congress - NDTV News      |       India suspends cross-LoC trade, says Pak-based elements misusing trade routes - Times of India      |       EC lets off Union minister Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi with warning for 'Modiji ki sena' remark - Times of India      |       CPM candidate's car attacked in West Bengal's Islampur; police resort to lathi charge after protesting... - Firstpost      |       Rahul Gandhi: PM is missing the link between national security and livelihood security - The Hindu      |       EVM glitches mar voting in seven states - Times of India      |       Christian Michel seeks bail to celebrate Easter; Delhi court reserves order - Times of India      |       Mehbooba Mufti tells Omar Abdullah to eat almonds to improve memory as both spar over Pragya Thakur - Scroll.in      |       Man Hurled Shoe at GVL Narsimha Rao for 'Media Attention', Delhi Police Releases Him - News18      |       Mueller report into Trump-Russia released - BBC News      |       Satellite Images Show Activity At North Korea's Nuclear Site: US Report - NDTV News      |       6.1-magnitude earthquake causes light damage in Taiwan capital, east coast - The Hindu      |       Gunmen kill at least 14 bus passengers in Pakistan’s Balochistan province - Hindustan Times      |       Jet Airways employees seek Prime Minster's intervention to solve their woes - Moneycontrol.com      |       Reliance’s Q4 standalone profit falls for first time in 17 quarters: Key takeaways - Economic Times      |       Mahindra, Ford sign agreement to co-develop midsize SUV - Team-BHP      |       How Mukesh Ambani’s deal with Saudi Aramco would help RIL; top brokerages explain - The Financial Express      |       Unofficial TWRP now available for the Xiaomi Redmi Note 7 (lavender) - XDA Developers      |       Breaking: Galaxy S10 gets dedicated Night mode in camera with new update - SamMobile      |       Motorola One Vision, Motorola One Action Smartphones Tipped in New Leak - NDTV      |       Google Maps is asking some users how crowded their train rides are - XDA Developers      |       ‘Kalank exists so we can forget Zero’: Internet responds to Varun Dhawan, Alia Bhatt’s film with hilarious... - Hindustan Times      |       'Beyond My Control,' Says Ajay Devgn After Being Criticised For Co-Starring With Alok Nath - NDTV News      |       Tiger Shroff gets candid about the new track 'The Jawaani Song' from 'Student of the Year 2' - Times of India      |       Anupam Kher Tweets Adorable DDLJ GIF, Shah Rukh Khan Responds to 'Daddy Cool' - News18      |       World Cup 2019 Team: Pakistan Announce 15-Man Squad, Mohammad Amir Left Out - NDTV Sports      |       Hashim Amla makes South Africa World Cup squad - The Hindu      |       Unfortunate to see so many people going after MS Dhoni: Virat Kohli to India Today - India Today      |       KKR sweat over Russell's fitness ahead of key clash - Cricbuzz      |       NASA exoplanet hunter TESS finds Earth dimension planet - The Lincoln Observer      |       Universe’s Very First Molecular Bond has been Observed in Space for the First Time - News18      |       Antares Rocket Carrying Cygnus Spacecraft Filled With NASA Cargo for ISS - NDTV      |       Scientists discover eco-friendly material for refrigerators and ACs - ANI News      |       Managing diabetes key to lowering kidney disease - SciDev.Net      |       Beware! Skipping Breakfast May Lead To Many Health Problems - NDTV News      |       Scientists spur brain activity in dead pigs, spark bioethical debate - Telegraph India      |       Board of Health unanimously votes to extend MMR vaccine requirement - News 12 Brooklyn      |      

Talking Point


Supreme Court Did Away With The Troublesome Part Of Section 377

It is important to remember that the apex court has not scrapped Section 377


supreme-court-did-away-with-the-troublesome-part-of-section-377

four-judge Supreme Court Bench led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra did the most sensible thing. As Chief Justice Dipak Misra wrote: “Section 377 IPC, so far as it penalizes any consensual sexual activity between two adults, be it homosexuals (man and a man), heterosexuals (man and a woman) and lesbians (woman and a woman), cannot be regarded as constitutional. However, if anyone, by which we mean both a man and a woman, engages in any kind of sexual activity with an animal, the said aspect of Section 377 IPC is constitutional and it shall remain a penal offence under Section 377 IPC.”

The petitioners were rightly and only concerned with consenting adults engaged in homosexual relationship implied in Section 377. The Supreme Court rightly responded declaring that consensual sex between two adults of the same sex cannot be an offence.

The four judges were overturning the earlier Suresh Koushal verdict of the court which had overturned the Delhi High Court verdict de-criminalising homosexuality. The present judgment had to establish the legal rationale against the Suresh Koushal verdict. But the court in doing so has gone a little too poetic, too rhetorical and too ideological in putting forward the doctrine of “transformative constitutionalism”. Chief Justice Dipak Misra says, “Our Constitution has been perceived to be transformative in the sense that the interpretation of its provisions should not be limited to the mere literal meaning of its words; instead they ought to be given a meaningful construction which is reflective of their intent and purpose in consonance with the changing times.” This is fuzzy thinking at best. Even the distinction that has been sought to be made between “constitutional morality” and “social morality” is unconvincing.

The crux of the issue is that fundamental rights cannot be violated even if they concern just an individual or a small group of individuals. Chief Justice Misra rightly states: “...for the language employed in Part III of the Constitution as well as the intention of the framers of our Constitution mandates that the Courts must step in whenever there is a violation of the fundamental rights, even if the right/s of a single individual is/are in peril.”

Justice Indu Malhotra in her concurrent judgment has reiterated the point: “The mere fact that the LGBT persons constitute a “minuscule fraction” of the country’s population cannot be a ground to deprive them of their Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Part III of the Constitution. Even though the LGBT constitute a sexual minority, members of the LGBT community are citizens of this country who are equally entitled to the enforcement of their Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 15, 19, and 21. “

Both Justices Rohinton Mistry and D.Y.Chandrachud had traced the origins of Section 377 to English law based on Judaeo-Christian principles, and both said that like in the triple talaq case, when an idea or principle militates against common sense and rationality, then the offending provision must go. But all of them had to stop short of scrapping the provision in toto. They held that only consenting adults of a same-sex relationship will be free from the penal provisions of Section 377. Justice Chandrachud was quite unhappy with the fact the government did not take a stand in the matter.

advertisement