nti.media
Will set up panel to study 'One Nation, One Election': PM Modi - Times of India      |       The Hindu Explains: How litchi toxin is causing the deaths of undernourished children in Muzaffarpur - The Hindu      |       ‘Won’t allow chanting of religious slogans in Parliament’: Speaker Om Birla - Hindustan Times      |       In Devendra Fadnavis Attending Sena Foundation Day, Message From Sena-BJP - NDTV News      |       Watch: Athawale’s witty speech taking dig at Rahul evokes laughter from PM Modi - The Indian Express      |       Sexual Harassment case: Police reinstate husband, kin of CJI complainant - The Indian Express      |       Shikhar Dhawan posts emotional message after being ruled out of World Cup - Times of India      |       ICC World Cup 2019: Steve Waugh excludes England, shocks everyone with his choice of semi-finalists - Hindustan Times      |       New Zealand vs South Africa Live Score, ICC World Cup 2019 Match at Birmingham: Van der Dussen Leads SA to 241/6 - News18      |       World Cup 2019: Pakistan Cricket Board Chief Phones Sarfaraz Ahmed After Loss To India - NDTV News      |       'Such Acts of Assault Would Scare Citizens': HC Lambasts Delhi Police Over Mukherjee Nagar Case - News18      |       Parliament: BJP's Heckling of Opposition MPs a Display of Brazen Majoritarian Bullying - The Wire      |       Day after doctors call off strike, SC refuses urgent hearing on plea seeking increased security - The Indian Express      |       Mettur Dam water being released to ease Chennai water crisis: CM Palaniswami - Livemint      |       Has "The Sacrificial Lamb" Arrived?: New Recordings In Khashoggi Murder - NDTV News      |       Probe Team Charges 4 Suspects with Murder over Downing of Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 - News18      |       Trump rehashes gripes, rips ‘radical’ Democrats in 2020 launch - The Hindu      |       US mulling 15% cap on H-1B visa for Indians - Times of India      |       HDFC Buys 51.2% Stake in Apollo Munich Health for Rs1,350 crore, to Merge it with HDFC ERGO - Moneylife      |       IL&FS auditors BSR, Deloitte facing probe heat from six agencies - Livemint      |       As Jet Airways Case Lands in NCLT, What's in Store for the Debt-ridden Airline? - News18      |       Masayoshi Son sees jaw-dropping $1.8-trillion value of SoftBank-backed companies in these many years - The Financial Express      |       Samsung Galaxy Note10 will have a Sound on Display technology - GSMArena.com news - GSMArena.com      |       Motorola One Pro press renders show four rear cameras, waterdrop notch, and more - 91mobiles      |       Save up to £210 on a new Samsung Galaxy A device with this excellent cashback offer - TechRadar      |       Virtual Vikings: how volumetric capture is making VR feel real - TechRadar      |       Avengers Endgame to re-release with a deleted scene, new post-credit tribute to break Avatar’s all-time... - Hindustan Times      |       Janhvi And Ananya Put Their Most Fashionable Foot Forward At The Grazia Millennial Awards - NDTV Movies      |       Cast, Crew Of Show Claim Attack By Goons, Harrassment By Cops In Mumbai - NDTV News      |       Sushmita Sen Shares Fun Moments of Dancing with Daughters on Brother Rajeev Sen’s Wedding - News18      |       What is Inzamam doing in England, asks ex-Pakistan skipper - Greater Kashmir      |       Fit Mohammed Shami My Biggest Achievement, Says Conditioning Coach Shankar Basu - NDTV News      |       Rating all the AC Milan players for the 2018-19 season - SempreMilan      |       ICC World Cup 2019, Australia vs Bangladesh: Top 5 player battles – Aaron Finch and Co wary of Shakib... - Hindustan Times      |       Two Earth-like planets just 12.5 light yrs away, orbiting red dwarf: Study - Business Standard      |       From pole to pole, 2 expeditions, 110 years apart: ISRO`s epic tweet ahead of Chandrayaan 2 - Zee News      |       You Can Learn About The Sun's Mysterious Past by Studying The Moon's Crust, Claims NASA - Mashable India      |       How Did NASA Put Men On The Moon? One Harrowing Step At A Time - NDTV      |       Breast Cancer Raises Diabetes, Heart Disease Risk - News18      |       News Facebook posts can predict and identify health conditions: Study - Elets      |       Vitamin D may not reduce heart risk - Business Standard      |       Disease that turns babies' lips blue identified - Deccan Herald      |      

Talking Point


Supreme Court Did Away With The Troublesome Part Of Section 377

It is important to remember that the apex court has not scrapped Section 377


supreme-court-did-away-with-the-troublesome-part-of-section-377

four-judge Supreme Court Bench led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra did the most sensible thing. As Chief Justice Dipak Misra wrote: “Section 377 IPC, so far as it penalizes any consensual sexual activity between two adults, be it homosexuals (man and a man), heterosexuals (man and a woman) and lesbians (woman and a woman), cannot be regarded as constitutional. However, if anyone, by which we mean both a man and a woman, engages in any kind of sexual activity with an animal, the said aspect of Section 377 IPC is constitutional and it shall remain a penal offence under Section 377 IPC.”

The petitioners were rightly and only concerned with consenting adults engaged in homosexual relationship implied in Section 377. The Supreme Court rightly responded declaring that consensual sex between two adults of the same sex cannot be an offence.

The four judges were overturning the earlier Suresh Koushal verdict of the court which had overturned the Delhi High Court verdict de-criminalising homosexuality. The present judgment had to establish the legal rationale against the Suresh Koushal verdict. But the court in doing so has gone a little too poetic, too rhetorical and too ideological in putting forward the doctrine of “transformative constitutionalism”. Chief Justice Dipak Misra says, “Our Constitution has been perceived to be transformative in the sense that the interpretation of its provisions should not be limited to the mere literal meaning of its words; instead they ought to be given a meaningful construction which is reflective of their intent and purpose in consonance with the changing times.” This is fuzzy thinking at best. Even the distinction that has been sought to be made between “constitutional morality” and “social morality” is unconvincing.

The crux of the issue is that fundamental rights cannot be violated even if they concern just an individual or a small group of individuals. Chief Justice Misra rightly states: “...for the language employed in Part III of the Constitution as well as the intention of the framers of our Constitution mandates that the Courts must step in whenever there is a violation of the fundamental rights, even if the right/s of a single individual is/are in peril.”

Justice Indu Malhotra in her concurrent judgment has reiterated the point: “The mere fact that the LGBT persons constitute a “minuscule fraction” of the country’s population cannot be a ground to deprive them of their Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Part III of the Constitution. Even though the LGBT constitute a sexual minority, members of the LGBT community are citizens of this country who are equally entitled to the enforcement of their Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 15, 19, and 21. “

Both Justices Rohinton Mistry and D.Y.Chandrachud had traced the origins of Section 377 to English law based on Judaeo-Christian principles, and both said that like in the triple talaq case, when an idea or principle militates against common sense and rationality, then the offending provision must go. But all of them had to stop short of scrapping the provision in toto. They held that only consenting adults of a same-sex relationship will be free from the penal provisions of Section 377. Justice Chandrachud was quite unhappy with the fact the government did not take a stand in the matter.

advertisement