nti.media
Caste takes a back seat to Narendra Modi’s appeal in Karnataka - Times of India      |       Post-poll survey: explaining the Modi sweep across regions - The Hindu      |       In Move To Quit, Rahul Gandhi Finds Support In Sister Priyanka: Sources - NDTV News      |       Avoid Making Loose Remarks in Media; Shun VIP Culture: PM Modi Instructs New MPs - News18      |       Feelers Sent out to Foreign Leaders on Availability for Modi's Swearing-In Ceremony - The Wire      |       In outreach to minorities, PM Modi wants to win trust, end ‘imaginary fear’ - Hindustan Times      |       Jagan meets KCR at Pragathi Bhavan - The Hans India      |       "Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas And Now Sabka Vishwas": PM Modi Speech At NDA Meet - NDTV      |       CBI Arrests Lawyer Representing Accused In Narendra Dhabolkar Murder Case - NDTV News      |       ‘Azadi for Islam’: How Zakir Musa became founder of Kashmir’s first al Qaeda affiliated group - Scroll.in      |       Japan trade a problem for Trump, but not as bad as China - The Indian Express      |       Pakistan PM Warns Against Risk Of War In Region Amid Iran Tensions - NDTV News      |       Theresa May becomes second UK PM to resign over Brexit - Hindustan Times      |       The cost of glory — Climbing Mount Everest - Times of India      |       India's Jet Airways founder held at Mumbai airport - Gulf News      |       Investors wealth increased by Rs 6 lakh crore in a historic week, Sensex climbs 1,500 pts - Moneycontrol.com      |       Karnataka CET 2019 result expected to be declared today; check at kea.kar.nic.in - Scroll.in      |       Global tech companies shun Huawei after US ban - The Asian Age      |       New image shows off the Redmi K20 in Blue color with a pop-up selfie camera - GSMArena.com news - GSMArena.com      |       Vivo Z5x with punch-hole display, 5,000mAh battery launched: Price, specifications - BGR India      |       iOS 12.3.1 Update Released for iPhone, iPad With Bug Fixes: How to Download and Install - Gadgets 360      |       Weird 'ghost touch' display issue noticed on OnePlus 7 Pro - NewsBytes      |       Photo: Gauri Khan's birthday message for Karan Johar is sure to grab your attention - Times of India      |       Sylvester Stallone says he never expected to make it in the movies - DAWN.com      |       India’s Most Wanted box office day 1: Arjun Kapoor’s film opens lower than Aladdin, Vivek Oberoi’s PM... - Hindustan Times      |       Pics: Kareena Kapoor And Saif Ali Khan Host Kunal Kemmu's Birthday Party - NDTV Movies      |       No need to press the panic button, believes Jadeja - Cricbuzz - Cricbuzz      |       ICC Cricket World Cup 2019: Allan Border picks Virat ..an and Aaron Finch as top captains in mega tournament - Firstpost      |       ‘Experienced’ Sachin Tendulkar feels Asif Ali’s huge loss ahead of World Cup - CricTracker      |       Charles Leclerc demands explanation from Ferrari after Q1 blunder - ESPN      |       SpaceX launches 60 Starlink satellites - The Hans India      |       NASA Announces Contract for Space Station to Orbit Moon - NDTV News      |       NASA's Mars 2020 mission conducts flight test for Mars touchdown - Xinhua | English.news.cn - Xinhua      |       Eighteen Earth-sized exoplanets discovered - The Indian Express      |       US approves world’s costliest drug to treat rare childhood disorder - Hindustan Times      |       Artificial Intelligence Finer Than Humans In Detecting Lung Cancer - DailyWellnessPro      |       Unhealthy food at work may up risk of lifestyle ailments: Study - Express Healthcare      |       Daily Self-Weighing May Help Cut Holiday Weight Gain - The Sentinel Assam      |      

States


HC holds IAS officer guilty of contempt, sends him to jail

Justice M.V. Muralidaran held the two officials guilty of disobeying orders passed by the Madurai Bench of the High Court


hc-holds-ias-officer-guilty-of-contempt-sends-him-to-jail

In a significant judgement, the Madras High Court on Wednesday sentenced IAS officer M.K. Shanmuga Sundaram, serving as Development Commissioner of the Madras Export Processing Zone (MEPZ), an entity functioning under the Union Ministry of Commerce and Industry, and its Assistant Development Commissioner N. Rajalingam to two weeks’ imprisonment in a contempt of court case.

Justice M.V. Muralidaran held the two officials guilty of disobeying orders passed by the Madurai Bench of the High Court in favour of beach sand mining firms V.V. Minerals and Transworld Garnet India Private Limited. He also directed them to pay a fine of Rs 5,000 each within three weeks or undergo two more weeks of simple imprisonment.

“Punishing a person for contempt of court is indeed a drastic step, and normally, such action should be taken with circumspection. At the same time, it is not only the power conferred upon the court but also its duty to uphold and maintain the dignity of the court and majesty of law which may call for such an extreme step.

“If, for proper administration of justice, and to ensure due compliance with the order passed by the court, a compulsion is thrust upon the court to take a strict view under the Contempt of Courts Act of 1971, the court should not hesitate to enforce its own order by exercising the power of contempt inasmuch as it is also the duty of the court to enforce its own order.

“Otherwise, the person in whose favour the order, judgment or decree is passed will be not only losing his confidence in the court approached for justice but also the entire proceedings will be rendered meaningless. Consequently, the sanctity of the court’s proceedings would also become a mockery and an empty formality,” the judge said.

The issue relates to MEPZ having passed an order on October 28, 2016, suspending the Letter of Permission (LoP) granted to the beach sand mining firms in 1995 to set up their export-oriented units in the special economic zone. The suspension was ordered on the basis of a letter received from the then Tirunelveli Collector, accusing the firms of engaging in illegal mining.

The two firms filed individual writ petitions in the Madurai Bench of the High Court, challenging the suspension orders, and obtained an interim stay on May 25, 2017. In the meantime, the 1995 LoP expired on April 22, 2017, and the firms applied for renewal. The officials, in turn, issued notices on October 9, 2017, questioning why renewal should not be denied.

Taking exception to such action, the writ petitioners filed the present contempt of court applications on the ground that refusal to renew the LoP amounted to disobeying the stay orders passed by the court. The petitioners’ counsel, S. Meenakshi Sundaram, contended that the officials had deliberately flouted court orders by not renewing the LoP.

Accepting the contention, the judge said, “The act of the respondent contemnors certainly amounts to wilful and deliberate defiance of the order of the court. A reading of the proceedings dated October 9, 2017, shows that such proceedings have been passed after recording the order of interim stay passed by this court. Therefore, by no stretch of imagination, the proceedings can be said to have been passed accidentally.”

advertisement