nti.media
Naresh Goyal quits: First act of gripping drama ends, Jet's fate now up in the air - Economic Times      |       "Final Assault On Poverty": Rahul Gandhi's Rs 6,000-a-Month Dole Promise - NDTV News      |       SC Issues Notice to CBI in Disproportionate Assets Case Against Mulayam Singh, Akhilesh Yadav - News18      |       Congress fields Karti in Sivaganga, Sudarshana Nachiappan protests - The Hindu      |       Indian Air Force inducts combat-ready Chinook helicopters - Economic Times      |       Kamal Haasan won't contest Lok Sabha polls, his party makes tall promises in manifesto - The News Minute      |       Election Tracker LIVE: Paralympics Games Winner Deepa Malik From Haryana Joins BJP - News18      |       Nitin Gadkari files nomination; says will win with a bigger margin - Times of India      |       Hindu Girls Abducted in Pakistan Approach Court for Protection, One Held for Assisting in Forced Marriage - News18      |       Trump didn't coordinate with Russia in 2016, Robert Mueller declares in report - The Hindu      |       Israeli PM To Cut Short US Visit After Rocket Injures Five In Tel Aviv - NDTV News      |       British PM Theresa May Faces Pressure to Step Down to Save Brexit - News18      |       Sensex, Nifty Log Biggest Single-Day Decline In A Month - BloombergQuint      |       Ex-McKinsey chief Rajat Gupta on Trump firing Preet Bharara - Quartz      |       Tesla Model 3 vs. 10 Top Selling Cars In US ... Tesla Solar Roof Install ... Tesla S-3-XY Comes To Life — #CleanTechnica Top 20 - CleanTechnica      |       Mindtree board, leadership on the same page: CEO Rostow Ravanan - Livemint      |       As Apple Embarks on The Services Era, Its Biggest Competition Isn’t Netflix But Amazon Prime - News18      |       Moto G7, Motorola One smartphones launched in India: Price, specifications, features - Hindustan Times      |       OPPO's first 5G smartphone gets 5G CE certificate - ETTelecom.com      |       Poco F1 price slashed by Rs. 2,000 for 6 GB + 128 GB model after Game Turbo Mode update - gizmochina      |       Deepika Padukone’s Chhapaak look gets its ‘biggest cheerleader’ in Kangana’s sister Rangoli, an acid... - Hindustan Times      |       Lok Sabha Polls 2019: Time is right for 'PM Narendra Modi', makers bet big on the biopic - Moneycontrol.com      |       Will act as Sita, ghost, friend or lover: Nayanthara shuts down Radha Ravi in style - The News Minute      |       Priyanka Chopra admits to Facetime sex during 'long stints apart' with husband Nick Jonas - In.com      |       Cloudy Skies in Jaipur Ahead of Rajasthan-Punjab Clash - The Weather Channel      |       Pant fires Delhi Capital to emphatic win - Nagaland Post      |       MS Dhoni uploads a super cute video with Ziva. You cannot miss this - India Today      |       Muscle-Russell slays the SRH challenge - Cricbuzz      |       ‘Chandrayaan 2 will carry NASA’s laser instruments to Moon’ - BusinessLine      |       NASA Publishes Images of Giant Meteor Explosion Over Bering Sea - NDTV      |       Apocalypse Now: An Asteroid Hit Could Wipe Out Life on Earth Again, Scientists Raise Concern - News18      |       How Jupiter Almost Became a Hot Jupiter - Interesting Engineering      |       Obesity Could Cause Reproductive Problems In Women With Type 1 Diabetes - NDTV News      |       Read About This New Therapy That Treats ‘Tennis Elbow’ Without Surgery - The Sentinel Assam      |       Damage to sperm DNA can lead to repeat miscarriages : study - ETHealthworld.com      |       Eating later in the day could be linked to obesity - Business Standard      |      

Nation


LS Passes Bill Providing Quota For Upper Castes

The government introduced the Constitution (124th Amendment) Bill, 2019 and got it passed the same day by a special majority as mandatorily required in a division with 323 "ayes" and 3 "noes"


ls-passes-bill-providing-quota-for-upper-castes

The Lok Sabha on Tuesday night passed the "historic" Constitution amendment bill to provide 10 per cent quota for upper castes in government service and higher educational institutions, with the opposition backing it despite reservations over the timing and calling it an "election gimmick".

Racing against time, the government, which is eyeing upper caste votes in the coming general elections after its losses in recent Assembly elections, introduced the Constitution (124th Amendment) Bill, 2019 and got it passed the same day by a special majority as mandatorily required in a division with 323 "ayes" and 3 "noes".

Apparently, not wanting to send wrong signals, the opposition members too broadly supported the measure.

The passage was marked by a walkout by Deputy Speaker M. Thambidurai of the AIADMK, who said that reservations for economically weaker sections cannot ensure social justice. AIADMK, considered friendly to BJP, has been opposing the government on various issues, of late, including the triple talaq bill. 

Top leaders including Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Sonia Gandhi 
and Rahul Gandhi were present at the time of the Bill's passage.

The House witnessed a six-hour-long discussion in which government sought to allay apprehensions and dismiss criticism that the 10
per cent quota based on economic criteria would not pass Supreme Court muster because of the 50 per cent cap on reservations set by the apex court.

Replying to the debate on the Bill, Social Justice Minister Thawarchand Gehlot said the measure is a "historic decision" taken by the Modi government in accordance with Prime Minister's policy of "development for all" and a "happy" moment for all the sections, including Brahmin, Thakur, Patel, Baniya and even those belonging to Christian and Muslim communities who will benefit by it.

Referring to the opposition criticism about the timing, he accepted that the bill has come late but "our intentions are good and the 
Constitution amendment will pass the muster in Supreme Court if anybody challenges it there".

He also dismissed the opposition charge that the Bill was brought in a hurry and said the issue has been debated for long in public and the government has consulted the common people and experts and their opinions taken. He rejected the opposition demand for referring the bill to a joint select committee for detailed consideration, saying it has already got delayed.

"There is and there was a need for this reservation to give them equal opportunity. It will bridge the gap between the rich and the poor. There are people in the general category who are living lives worse than that of those in the SCs and STs. They generally complain as to what is their fault in being born in these 
castes," he said.

On criticism about income and other limits for availing this proposed quota, Gehlot said it is the same as has been applied in the case of OBCs.

Earlier intervening in the discussion, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley rejected criticism that the quota for economically weaker sections will breach the 50
per cent cap set by the Supreme Court, saying that the limit is specific to the quota for the SCs/STs and socially and educationally backward classes.

He also dismissed criticism that the proposed quota would violate the basic structure of the Constitution and referred to the inclusion of the word "secular" in the Constitution during the Emergency.

"Today the time has come (for the quota of the upper caste) if we take the manifesto of all the parties which have pledged for affirmative action for the economically weaker sections. This bill ensures '
sabka saath, sabka vikas'. It is a move for equality and will enable social upliftment," Jaitley said.

Referring to the Supreme Court judgment in the Indira Sawhney case, the Finance Minister, himself an eminent lawyer, said the apex court struck down the government notification issued during the regime of P.V. Narasimha 
Rao, because the quota for economically weaker sections among the upper caste has not been provided in the Constitution.

He read out the promise of the Congress manifesto in 2014 which had said that the Congress is committed to finding a way forward for reservations for the economically weaker sections of all communities without disturbing the existing reservation for 
under-privileged communities.

Like the government eyeing the upper caste votes in the coming Lok Sabha elections, the opposition too did not oppose the measure but expressed reservations over whether it will pass judicial muster. They accused the government of bringing it on the last day of the last full session and asked if it is such a priority why it was not brought earlier.

Initiating the debate, K.V. Thomas of Congress said that the government has brought the bill "in haste" after BJP's losses in three Hindi heartland states and demanded it should be sent to a joint parliamentary committee (JPC) for scrutiny. 

"We are not against it (the bill). We support the concept. But the way you are doing it, (your) sincerity (is) questioned. Send it to JPC, why are you in hurry?" he said, adding that the bill can be discussed in February when the Parliament will meet to approve the vote on account. 

A crucial point made by opposition members, which was also echoed by ministers Ram Vilas Paswan and Anupriya Patel, was that reservation is good but where are the jobs in government. The ministers also used the opportunity to demand reservation in jobs in the private sector and in judicial appointments.

The Congress and other opposition members repeatedly taunted the government questioning it on the pre-poll promises of creating two crore jobs every year.

The BJP fielded members from diverse upper castes in the debate apart from the ministers and MPs from the weaker sections.

The Bill will come up in the Rajya Sabha whose business has been extended by a day till Wednesday. The Bill was cleared by the Union Cabinet on Monday.

advertisement